Tuesday, July 7, 2009

Annotated Paragraph: 5 Key Concepts & A Coke!

Below is a lesson I have used to introduce the 5 Key Concepts and the Media Triangle to grade 7 and 8 students. While the "concepts" seem boring, confusing and irrelevant at first; the students begin to understand the importance of the these concepts and are able to make connections to them, once a series of examples are given. The animated coke commercial (see below) is an excellent start to teaching about media's key concepts through the use of commercials. Student watch a lot of tv commercials at home but they rarely think beyond the intended message. The students really enjoy this media rich animated commercial because on the surface it mimics a popular video game (Grand Thief Auto) but it becomes ironic when the "bad guy" chooses to "give a little love" (perhaps because of his choice of beverage).

While all 5 Key Concepts and any of the 3 sides of the Media Triangle can be explored using this Coke commercial, the students and I focused on #2 Media texts contain beliefs and value messages. Specifically we analysed who or what is included, omitted and/or misrepresented? After watching the commercial for the 3rd time, they were able to get past the humour and identify a number of sexual and racial stereotypes. Here is the lesson:



An Introduction to the 5 Key Concepts and the Media Triangle

Two frameworks are used to help you understand media messages.

The first is the 5 Key Concepts of Media Literacy.




5 Key Concepts of Media Literacy Poster



The second is the Media Studies Triangle which examines 3 different points of view (the Media Text, the Audience, and the Production) in order to gain more meaning. All 3 points of view must be considered to fully understand the media text's meaning.




Use the activity sheet Media Studies Triangle to analyse various media text....




Let's analyse a few media texts together.....




A) Here is a Coke Commercial.....










B) Here is a PSA (Public Service Announcement) About Factory Farming Called "The Meatrix":








C) Here are Movie Posters.....








D) Now, with a partner or on your own, try using the "Media Studies Triangle" to analyse a Magazine....



Lego Club Magazine

Analysis of Media Text #1

Analyse Media Text Using the Five Key Concepts

LEGO Club Magazine
#4 Media texts reflect special interests (commercial, ideological, political).

Lego Club Magazine is not really a “magazine” at all. It is a twenty page, glossy, colourful advertisement for various Lego products created by Lego for young (ages 8-12), upper-middle class, and white males. The contest winners on pages 14-15 are all white males and the price of Lego kits (i.e. Lego Star Wars Death Star II $399.00) would exclude lower income families. The fact that media “intended for an audience is created for profit” is obvious in this “magazine” to critical viewers of media text. Perhaps not too obvious for the middle school students I teach.



My experience with teaching Media Literacy in a middle school for the first time last year has taught me that students enjoy a great deal of media text but have very little experience in deconstructing and analyzing any of it. All 5 Key Concepts, as well as the three sides of the Media Triangle, need to be discussed and taught about through a very large selection of examples (i.e. magazines, posters, video game sleeves, ads, commercials, etc.). Lego Magazine is just one example.


Lego Club Magazine is an excellent example of a media text which reflects commercial interests. Some of the questions students can explore include: Who created this text and why? It will be obvious to the students that LEGO created the text but some deeper analysis will be needed to uncover the reasons why. Students will begin to see that the “magazine” is created to entertain and inform its young audience; however, they will soon realize that the primary goal of the magazine is to sell more Lego kits. It is a catalogue dressed as a magazine.



Who benefits if the message is accepted? I would explain to my students how much my eight year old son loves getting his Lego Club Magazine in the mail. It makes him feel grown-up getting mail sent directly to him. He often visits the website, http://www.legoclub.com/, as well for online games and information about new products. Therefore, he does benefit from the magazine. However, it is the company which benefits, actually profits, if the message in the magazine is accepted. The message being, you need more Lego kits to be happy.



Finally, we must look at Who may be disadvantaged? The disadvantaged are those who are left out. Lego used to be plastic blocks that all children used, with their imagination, to create all kinds of structures. That has changed with the integration of Lego and a large number of commercial movies (i.e. Star Wars, Indiana Jones, and Sponge Bob). Now Lego sells expensive Lego kits which exclude a large group of children whose families cannot afford a $69.99 Lego Ferrari kit. Females are also excluded from this “club” because all of the products are geared towards typical male interests (i.e. Lego Racers, Lego City, and Lego Castle). It is ironic that during my school’s First Lego League Robotics Competition it was the two girls on the team of mostly boys that did the best in the competition because of their problem-solving and communication skills. Lego is missing out by excluding this market of consumers.

Welcome to My Locker.....







Rationale: Next year I'm teaching Media Literacy in a middle school computer lab. I would like my students to create a "virtual locker" with reflections, rants, reviews, analysis, and media products all posted to their Blog or webpage. This paperless pursuit will be a greater challenge in some ways (i.e. uploading, scanning, downloading, etc.) and much easier in other ways (i.e. I'm not an artist or at all creative beyond Photoshop). My plan is to create the virtual locker of a middle school student with a variety of media text including:




Child Soldier Lesson Plan

School Binder (Reflective Journals #1, #2, #3 and even #4; Chapter Review, Annotated Paragraph, the Movie Lesson Plan, etc.)